A crowded field is jostling to replace retiring Rep. Vern Buchanan in Tuesday's primary
By Steve Newborn
August 13, 2026 at 1:56 PM EDT
With Buchanan retiring after 20 years in Congress, nine candidates have filed to run in 16th District – three Republicans, five Democrats and one with no party affiliation. A political scientist helps weigh the field.
U.S. Rep. Vern Buchanan, one of the deans of Congress, is taking his victory lap. There's a spirited race in Tuesday's primaries to succeed him.
Buchanan is retiring after representing the congressional district centered on Manatee and Sarasota counties for 20 years. That longevity undoubtedly chased away countless challengers.
That's not true anymore.
Nine candidates have filed to run in 16th Congressional District – three Republicans, five Democrats and one with no party affiliation.
Saint Leo University political scientist Frank Orlando said the eventual winner is likely to be a Republican, based on the district's voting history. And the favorite is Sydney Gruters, who has been endorsed by President Donald Trump.
"Gruters has all the institutional support on this," Orlando said. "Her husband (state Sen. Joe Gruters) is the (Republican National Committee) chair. She has all the backing. She's spent the most money. Would be difficult to see an anti-Gruters vote. It's a three-way race (with Ed Pope and Eddie Speir), although there's probably two front-runners, but I would say Gruters to me is the favorite."
ALSO READ: 'Time to pass the torch': Florida congressman Vern Buchanan announces retirement
The Democrats are led by former Sarasota Mayor Kelly Kirschner and Jan Schneider, who has repeatedly lost to Buchanan. Orlando said that experience on the ballot may not translate into her winning Tuesday's primary.
"Just because someone has been a candidate many times in a row doesn't give them an advantage. It just means that it wasn't appealing to high-quality Democrats in the past," Orlando said. "In an open seat with a little bit of shifted lines, that piques the interest of quality Democratic candidates. And so, to me, when you've got mayoral experience in Sarasota, you're much more likely to jump into this race, and I think that would be my prediction."
He says even though the district now includes very blue St. Petersburg, it still leans Republican. And Buchanan has repeatedly won more than 60% of the vote.
"It's a huge uphill climb (for Democrats)," he said. "On average, this is about a district that reflects the breakdown of the state in terms of how much Trump won it by versus how much you won this district by, and so you would need a huge overperformance to win."
Map of Florida's 16th congressional district. (1600x1115, AR: 1.4349775784753362)
Buchanan is retiring after representing the congressional district centered on Manatee and Sarasota counties for 20 years. That longevity undoubtedly chased away countless challengers.
That's not true anymore.
Nine candidates have filed to run in 16th Congressional District – three Republicans, five Democrats and one with no party affiliation.
Saint Leo University political scientist Frank Orlando said the eventual winner is likely to be a Republican, based on the district's voting history. And the favorite is Sydney Gruters, who has been endorsed by President Donald Trump.
"Gruters has all the institutional support on this," Orlando said. "Her husband (state Sen. Joe Gruters) is the (Republican National Committee) chair. She has all the backing. She's spent the most money. Would be difficult to see an anti-Gruters vote. It's a three-way race (with Ed Pope and Eddie Speir), although there's probably two front-runners, but I would say Gruters to me is the favorite."
ALSO READ: 'Time to pass the torch': Florida congressman Vern Buchanan announces retirement
The Democrats are led by former Sarasota Mayor Kelly Kirschner and Jan Schneider, who has repeatedly lost to Buchanan. Orlando said that experience on the ballot may not translate into her winning Tuesday's primary.
"Just because someone has been a candidate many times in a row doesn't give them an advantage. It just means that it wasn't appealing to high-quality Democrats in the past," Orlando said. "In an open seat with a little bit of shifted lines, that piques the interest of quality Democratic candidates. And so, to me, when you've got mayoral experience in Sarasota, you're much more likely to jump into this race, and I think that would be my prediction."
He says even though the district now includes very blue St. Petersburg, it still leans Republican. And Buchanan has repeatedly won more than 60% of the vote.
"It's a huge uphill climb (for Democrats)," he said. "On average, this is about a district that reflects the breakdown of the state in terms of how much Trump won it by versus how much you won this district by, and so you would need a huge overperformance to win."
Map of Florida's 16th congressional district. (1600x1115, AR: 1.4349775784753362)